I have choose the color brown since its more of a natural color and i have never tried out gel liners before. It was a very good price, and i said that i would try it. It came also with a brush; i wish it was a angled brush for easy application, so if you don’t like this one you could use one from your own. when i went home and tested it out on my hand it was SUPER creamy and the color is a same dupe of the MAC's "Teddy" eye kohl if you want to get it and not spend alot of money; but instead this is a gel liner. The MAC "Teddy" one has red shimmer on the base, but the Maybelline has more of a gold shimmer but it doesn’t have lots of difference.
The product also says that it stays 24 hours which actually i don’t care if it was waterproof, but that was a good thing about it. When i tried it the next morning on my eye it was easy flowing and smooth to have on which is really good. I have a bad habit of rubbing my eyes and so whenever i rub and i have liquid liner or eye kohl on my upper lash line, it always smudges to my hand. But, this one i was literally rubbing it with my hands and it wasn’t going off or smudging. When i got home i have just washed my face with my Neutrogena Face wash and it instantly went off which wasn’t hard which is a good thing. Overall, i am very impressed with the quality of this product i am willing to buy another one when this finishes. Also i want to try the L'Oreal one and when i do ill do a review and say which one i like more :) Let me know what you think about it if you have tried it, also what do you think of the L'Oreal one?
Hope you enjoyed!
xoxo,
Allie